I agree I wouldn't want to ban anyone as they could easily ban me, of course if they haven't uploaded any videos then that's not a problem but it would be disastrous if my favourite sparring partner for example were to ban me, what then. ?
(I thought Barackula the musical would stir some debate not a rousing speech from Kucinich.)

I really enjoy this site so thanks Admin and thanks to the other members here, watching some of your videos and reading some of the comments made me want to join in the first place.
I also think that new users (I'm new myself, 2+ months) should contribute more than just the occasional comment on a video before threatening to never return, and yes before anyone mentions I'm all for freedom of speech but shouldn't you have earned it a bit first before chiming in with threats of never returning?

I visit ATS occasionally and am impressed by the general civility they have towards each other surely we can manage the same.

While I agree that only true members of the site should be allowed to comment, the 5 video rule is somewhat irritating. This site is about disclosure, so if you are busy researching, there may be little to disclose on video, but much information to add via a comment.

For example, when someone discloses a video of a strange animal that I can research, find the answer to and post... That is a contribution to the site. I shouldn't have to make a video just to make a point. Dumb idea. Let those who post the videos decide.

Well, as said above. Strict rules apply for comments to videos, podcasts and photos from now on instead of the video upload policy. Thread closed.