Digital ID could leave UK with China-style social credit system

Sir Keir Starmer is pushing for mandatory ID cards, claiming they will address illegal immigration. However, critics argue that the real solution lies in stopping improper entry to the country, not monitoring citizens. Past arguments for ID cards remain weak, while opposition has grown as technology advances.

The dangers of such cards, evidenced by abuses in other countries like China, illustrate the potential for state overreach and erosion of privacy. Many believe that ID cards could lead to unwarranted surveillance and restrictions on citizens.

"You now need them to catch a train, apply for a job, buy a SIM card, open a bank account or rent a flat. This puts vast powers of surveillance and control into the hands of state officials," says Daniel Hannman of the Telegraph.

While some conditions for state benefits may be justified, Starmer's proposal for ID cards tied to employment is seen as fundamentally illiberal. Public opinion is currently split, but resistance is growing, with nearly 2 million signing a petition against the idea.